The DTC store checklist.
51 things we check on every food & beverage, pet and toy store before we design anything. Tick what you already have. Your progress saves in this browser.
Reviews & trust
Strangers need a reason to believe you before they'll try you.
The star rating is the first thing most shoppers look for. If it's buried below the fold, many never see it.
A rating count, a press quote or a short customer quote near the hero answers "is this any good?" right away.
Example: OLIPOP puts customer quotes near the top.
Product schema with an aggregate rating lets Google show stars and price, which lifts click-through.
How to check: paste a product URL into Google's Rich Results Test.
Shoppers read the 1- and 2-star reviews first. A helpful public reply often does more for trust than a perfect rating.
How to check: sort your reviews by lowest rating. Count how many have no reply.
Old reviews make a brand look quiet. Sort by newest and keep a post-purchase review request running.
Real kitchens, real dogs, real kids. Customer photos show scale and use better than studio shots.
Lab results, certifications, sourcing, safety testing, awards. Show it on the page, not in a footer PDF.
Example: Uncle Arnie's has lab results built into each product.
"Love it or we'll make it right" removes the risk of a first order, especially for food you haven't tasted.
Product page
The page that does the selling. Answer every question before it's asked.
Hero shot, scale or in-hand, close-up of texture or ingredients, in use, lifestyle, and a callout graphic.
Same lighting and crop across the catalog, sharp on retina screens, and not six versions of the same angle.
10–20 seconds: the pour, the crunch, the unboxing, the dog chasing it. Video answers questions photos can't.
Icons or badges for what matters to your buyer: vegan, 0g sugar, high protein, non-toxic, ages 3+, made in USA.
When flavors, strengths or sizes look alike, a short comparison ("which one is for me?") stops the hesitation.
Example: Graza compares its two oils side by side.
Swatches or images for flavors and colors, with sold-out options clearly marked.
For food, beverage, treats and supplements. Text (not just an image) is readable on mobile, by screen readers and by Google.
Show when and how to use it: recipes and pairings, routines, play ideas, training tips.
Example: Fishwife sells the occasion, not the tin.
Shelf life, allergens, sizing, shipping heat, "is it safe for puppies?" Answer the top five questions where people decide.
Once shoppers scroll into reviews and FAQs, the buy button should come with them.
"$2.50 per can" makes the 12-pack obviously better value than the 4-pack.
"Ships in 1–2 days. Free over $50." Surprises at checkout are a top reason for abandoned carts.
Harness sizing for pet gear, age and skill level for toys, servings per container for food.
Describe flavor, size and what's shown. It helps screen-reader users and image search.
Offer & order value
Same traffic, bigger orders, more reorders.
Coffee, snacks, treats, supplements, refills. Spell out what arrives, how often, and that it's easy to skip or cancel.
Example: Lovevery describes its subscription as a delivery plan.
A variety pack lowers the risk of a first order. Kits raise order value and save shoppers from matching pieces.
Example: Wild One's Walk Kits.
Set it about 20–30% above your average order value. Show the exact amount in the announcement bar, product page and cart.
Turns the threshold into a goal and pairs well with an add-on suggestion right below it.
"Pairs well with" or "complete the kit". One or two good suggestions beat a carousel of twelve.
Gift sets, notes and gift cards. Holiday and Mother's Day shoppers often aren't buying for themselves.
Fewer form fields on mobile. On WooCommerce this needs a payment plugin that supports wallets.
Homepage & navigation
Get first-time visitors to the right product fast.
A visitor from a TikTok or a retail shelf QR code should get it in five seconds, without scrolling.
New visitors don't know where to start. Point them at the product most people buy first.
Shop by age, by occasion, by dietary need, by dog size. Match how people think about the problem.
Example: Lovevery's "Shop by Age".
One line under the product name answers "why this one?" in the grid, before anyone clicks.
Example: Wild One does this on every card.
Holiday, summer, a new flavor drop. Your team should be able to do it from the theme editor, without a developer.
Try "choclate", "decaf" or "puppy" on your own store. No results means a lost sale.
Best on the product page too ("find this flavor near you"), not only on a separate page.
Example: Ellenos, which we built.
Mobile & speed
Most of your traffic is on a phone. Test it there.
Tap targets, variant pickers, the cart drawer, pop-ups that can be closed. Test on an actual iPhone in Safari, not just a resized desktop browser.
That's Google's "good" bar for Largest Contentful Paint. Slow pages lose shoppers and rankings.
Late-loading banners and review widgets push buttons down just as people tap. Google measures this as CLS.
Uninstalled apps often leave code behind. Every script slows the page a little.
A full-screen pop-up in the first second hides the product people came to see.
Retention & capture
The first order is expensive. The second one is where you make money.
A first-order offer, recipes, early access to drops. "Join our newsletter" isn't a reason.
Welcome, abandoned cart, post-purchase, replenishment and win-back. Flows quietly break more often than you'd think.
How to check: Blindspot, our Klaviyo audit app, reviews this every week.
Timed to when the product has been used, not the day it ships.
"Where's my order?" is the top support question for most stores. A tracking page with your brand and a buy-again button turns it into a sale.
On WooCommerce: OrderCtrl, our app, handles tracking, returns and order edits.
Referrals work especially well for food and pet brands, where people share what they love.
Pull the ten most common tickets from the last quarter. Each one should be answered on a product page, the FAQ or the shipping page.
SEO & sharing
The basics that decide whether people find you and click.
Titles of 30–60 characters, descriptions of 120–160 that sell the click, and one clear H1 per page.
A sentence or two helps search engines and shoppers. Filters should match how people shop (flavor, diet, size).
Especially after a migration. Old URLs with backlinks should redirect to the closest match, not the homepage.
We can fix most of this in one build.
Book a fit call and we'll tell you which three items would move sales most for your store.